Wendell harrison distinguished service professor in the political science department at the university of chicago, where i have taught since 1982. In contrast, offensive realists state that great powers can secure themselves only by maximizing their own power mearsheimer 2001, 21. Structural realismoffensive and defensive realism source. The theoretical goal is to advance a social evolutionary approach for understanding states security strategy or foreign policy in general.
It fundamentally differs from defensive realism by depicting great powers as. The former focuses on the international system and the latter on statelevel behaviour. Great powers are the main actors in world politics and the international system is anarchical. Realism arose as an opposing idea to idealism and nominalism. Glaser, it has been criticised both by offensive realists and other scholars. The scholars who use power transition theory or offensive realism to. Offensive realism is a structural theory belonging to the neorealist school of thought put forward by john mearsheimer in response to defensive realism. To be specific, defensive realism traces its roots from the 1979 book theory of international politics by kenneth waltz while offensive realism finds its foundation from the 2001 book the tragedy of great power politics by john j. There are many variants of realism, but they tend to share a set of common core characteristics. More specifically, i am a realist, which means that i believe that the great powers dominate the international system and they. Idealism is the approach to literature of writing about everything in its ideal from.
Japanese perceptions of chinas capabilities and intentions and of the offensive or defensive advantage of the geography of the nansei islands and chinese antiship ballistic missiles give an. Defensive neorealism is a structural theory derived from the school of realism in international relations theory. The literature on the rise of great powers in general and chinas rise, in particular, is widely divided into power transition theory, the realist camp offensive realism and defensive realism and the liberal school of thought. Offensive and defensive realism may be seen as different sides of the same coin. Japans grand strategy toward the korean peninsula and the alliance is informed by realist tenets, but these are defensive realist tenets rather than offensive realist ones. Offensive realism believes that states are inherently aggressive either by nature or because of an archy, andor that their aggressiveness is only limited by their. The field of international relations now has at least two varieties of structural realism, 2 probably three kinds of offensive realism, 3 end page 149 and several types of defensive realism, 4 in addition to neoclassical, contingent, specific, and generalist realism. Structural realism holds that the nature of the international structure. Offensive realism holds that the anarchic nature of the international system is responsible for the promotion of aggressive state behavior in international politics. Both offensive realism or and defensive realism dr draw from five, distinct tenets that form the foundation of both theories with minor variations.
A critique understanding state behaviour under anarchy, or developing an adequate theory of foreign policy, remains an important goal of the science of international relations. Sep 15, 2016 offensive realism is a structural theory belonging to the neorealist school of thought first postulated by john mearsheimer that holds the anarchic nature of the international system responsible. They share the basic beliefs of survivalism, statism state as the primary unit, selfhelp and anarchy. Download file to see previous pages the main differences between offensive and defensive realism are based on variations on how they see power and how much power is enough. Offensive realism, defensive realism, and the role of constraints. Mar 06, 2014 john mearsheimer is one of these pessimists and arguably one of the most prominent skeptics of chinas peaceful rise referring to chinas foreign policy which has sought to mitigate the china threat school of thought. Offensive realism is a structural theory belonging to the neorealist school of thought first postulated by john mearsheimer that holds the anarchic nature of the international system responsible. From offensive to defensive realism a social evolutionary interpretation of chinas security strategy tang shiping this chapter has two principal goals, one theoretical and one empirical. Toward a material and systemic foundation for offensive and defensive realism eric j. Offensive versus defensive realism contemporary arab affairs.
Offensive realism and defensive realism in the case of irans nuclear weapons. Between offensive and defensive realism the japanese abe governments security policy toward china. Defensive realism asserts that aggressive expansion as promoted by offensive realists upsets the tendency of states to conform to the balance of power theory, thereby decreasing the primary objective of the state, which they argue is ensuring its security. Besides waltz, theory of international politics, other examples of defensive realism. Defensive realism and the johns hopkins university. I argue that china has firmly evolved from an offensive realism state under mao zedong to a defensive realism state under deng xiaoping and thereafter. Besides waltz, theory of international politics, other examples of defensive realism include robert.
The field of international relations now has at least two varieties of structural realism, probably three kinds of offensive realism, and several types of defensive realism, in addition to. Between offensive and defensive realism the japanese abe. Defensive realism asserts that aggressive expansion as promoted by offensive realists upsets the tendency of states to conform to the balance of power theory. What is the difference between offensive realism and. Indeed, besides the distinction between offensive and defensive realism, there is also an overlooked parallel distinction between offensive and defensive liberalism. These are competitors that seek to explain the same phenomena and cut across the classicalneo divide. Doc offensive realism and defensive realism in the case. First, the article presents theories of offensive and defensive realism. Most important difference is that defensive variety argues that anarchy only provides incentives for expansion under certain conditions, while offensive variety holds that anarchy always provides incentives for expansion. I compare offensive realism mainly to waltzs theory, because mearsheimer himself casts waltz as the leading defensive realist and his primary target.
Japanese perceptions of chinas capabilities and intentions and of the offensive or defensive advantage of the geography of the nansei islands and chinese antiship ballistic missiles give an explanation for the shift in policy. Glaser and chaim kaufmann offensedefense theory offers an optimistic view of international politics based on the argument that war can be prevented if defense gains an advantage over offense. Neorealists hold the idea that anarchy is the nature of the international structure. By underscoring the major mechanisms behind this evolutionary process, i further argue that china is unlikely to revert to the offensive realism mindset in its past. This four fold division is based not only on a distinction between realism and liberalism, but also on an internal division inside each camp between offensive and defensive approaches. Mearsheimers worldoffensive realism and the struggle for. Despite defensive realism s significant contribution to international relations theory and its number of prominent proponents, such as kenneth waltz, stephen van evera, and charles l. Offensive realism in brief in its simplest form, my theory maintains that the basic structure of the international system forces states concerned about their security to compete with each other. Defensive realism gives a better account of the concert of europe, because it combines structural realism with nonrealist theories of state preferences. Americas nato allies, such as the baltic states, are used in the strategy of countering russia. According to defensive realism, which is more common. It finds its foundation in kenneth waltzs theory of. From offensive to defensive realism fudan university. In contrast to a simple difference in semantics, the theories of offensive and defensive realism are two, totally different approaches to an identical starting premise.
Nominalism believes that ideas are only names and have no practical application. Reaction to idealism reaction to the breakdown of international order that led to wwi. Offensive or defensive realism ghazala yasmin jalil institute of. Other articles where offensive realism is discussed. Oct, 2016 defensive neorealism is a structural theory derived from the school of realism in international relations theory. Doc offensive realism and defensive realism in the case of. It finds its foundation in kenneth waltzs theory of international politics, in. The theory of offensive realism offers dangerous and selfdefeating policy advice to both china and the us. The theoretical goal is to advance a social evolutionary approach for understand. Both of these have offensive and defensive variants. May 30, 2017 while retaining major elements of the defensive realist yoshida doctrine, the direction of policy change has been toward a more assertive policy. Structural realismoffensive and defensive realism oxford. What is the offensedefense balance and can we measure it. Pdf structural realismoffensive and defensive realism.
Most of these theories share a few common assumptions. If one adopts defensive realism, a deal with russia is at. Defensive realism sees power as a means of attaining stability or security, while offensive realism sees power as both means and ends for political stability. States do not cooperate, except during temporary alliances, but constantly seek to diminish their competitors power and to enhance their own. Offense, defense, and international politics by charles l. Offensive and defensive realism national chengchi university. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Rathbun a divide has opened up between offensive and defensive realism as to the relative scarcity of security in the international system, with powerful implications for the vision each approach offers about the. Chinas rise, great power, offensive realism, defensive. John mearsheimer offensive realism in brief genius. Offensive realism, thucydides traps, and the tragedy of. If one adopts offensive realism, trying to strike a bargain with russia makes no sense.
Realism and classical realism in making an appeal to classical realism it is necessary to consider, briefly, the main contours of realist thought and the distinct attributes of the classical school. Above all else, i am an international relations theorist. But critics of the offensive realist view emphasize common interests, global institutions, and domestic constraints, particularly since chinas rapid growth makes the country more open to and. In this article, the two main branches of structural realism, kenneth waltzs defensive realism and john mearsheimers offensive realism, are challenged on their own terms to assess whether. Defensive realism and the concert of europe cambridge core. Jun 18, 2019 the theory of offensive realism offers dangerous and selfdefeating policy advice to both china and the us. By underscoring the major mechanisms behind this evolutionary process, i further argue that china is unlikely to. John mearsheimers theory of offensive realism and the. Mearsheimers offensive realism in the postcold war world mearsheimers offensive realism 7 is also a structural theory of international politics that affords special attention to great powers, but claims to have relevance for other states as well to varying degrees mearsheimer 2001, 1722, 403 n. Realism focused on the truthful treatment of the common. The conclusion from defensive realism is that in some circumstances states can escape the security dilemma. Waltzs theory of international politics profoundly affected international relations theory. A social evolutionary interpretation of chinas security strategy i.
John mearsheimer is one of these pessimists and arguably one of the most prominent skeptics of chinas peaceful rise referring to chinas foreign policy which has sought to mitigate the china threat school of thought. Offensive realism and defensive realism are variants of structural realism. First outlined by kenneth waltz in his 1979 book theory of international politics, structural realism is subdivided into two factions. Defensive realism and japans approach toward korean. Defensive realism and offensive realism first emerged from the separate and contradicting works of two american political scientists. Underpinning his skepticism of chinas peaceful rise is a compelling formulation of offensive realism. Defensive realists state that countries with a strong willingness to balance power counterbalance and.
Mearsheimers main innovation is his theory of offensive realism that seeks to reformulate kenneth waltzs structural realist theory to explain from a structural point of departure the sheer amount of international aggression, which may be hard to reconcile with waltzs more defensive realism. John mearsheimers theory of offensive realism and the rise. I conclude that the book is a major theoretical advance. This difference is critical because defensive realism, as it informs japanese strategic choices, offers a far more optimistic outlook on japans support of. Structural realism, or neorealism, is a theory of international relations that says power is the most important factor in international relations. Sep 03, 2019 defensive realists argue that maintaining the power balance is the best way to safeguard the status quo and secure the state waltz 1979, 126.
Having committed to defensive realism, russia has so far not changed us offensive behavior. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Oct 14, 2017 in contrast to a simple difference in semantics, the theories of offensive and defensive realism are two, totally different approaches to an identical starting premise. Defensive realists state that countries with a strong willingness to balance power counterbalance.
596 444 476 840 758 378 1288 1177 752 1399 387 432 816 893 196 1194 1528 1118 1482 1447 1379 1504 1163 239 1025 1042 310 1218 1421 995 650 828 1089